how I love a good debate, Now you have no doubt @Oil Fry so lets look closely at the bird in question, its tail is short, its body is stumpy, they have been measured up to 14.2 cm. bigger than some of the smaller budgies, they can have a different colour on the shoulder but i have only seen white.. then I have to question how likely is it for it to be an amizoniian , in captivity I will think they are not so common, they was only discovered in 1991 and four was brought to England in 1993, as far as i know, I think I was one of the first to meet the species when it arrived but that makes me wonder if they have ever found there way into the pet trade. even today not too much is known about the habits of these birds in the wild apart from they do not hang about in large flocks but small groups of twenty at a maximum. OK there is more chance that it is a Brotogeris, but to be honest I am not sure, I will contact my daughter in law and see what she can find out as she can gain access to studies through Cambridge university, herself specialising in parrots in field studies across the world.